Are cars still the worst privacy product category?

We said yes a year ago. Time for a service check.

In partnership with

Patent boy

Are cars still the worst privacy product category?

THE HIGHWAY VERSION

🚕  Waymo has a newly granted US patent for a pickup code that helps you find your robotaxi without the car showing your name, your initials or where you're going.

🔢  Dispatch creates a random code that never repeats (think "ASDFGH" or a symbol). It lights up on the outside of the car only when it's a couple of blocks away, and it matches the code on your phone.

💰  Waymo carries over 500,000 rides a week and is valued at US$126 billion. Meanwhile, GM has paid more than US$230 million in settlements for selling drivers' data.

⚠️  Waymo's own cars still show riders' initials on the roof by default, and the patent does nothing about the cameras and data inside the car.

Find what’s slowing your GTM.

Most GTM problems aren’t one big failure. They’re one or two weak spots quietly dragging down the rest.

The free GTM Audit scores your go-to-market across four dimensions, then sequences a 90-day roadmap for your stage.

Drop your URL. Get your score in about 10 minutes.

Get My GTM Score

Two letters on the roof

One year ago, we reported on how cars are increasingly collecting your personal data, but cars were actually the worst product category for privacy.

I spotted a new patent that improves privacy for cars, and it got me thinking, are cars still the worst product category for privacy? And what steps have car manufacturers taken to improve?

Smart cars and autonomous vehicles are still storming ahead. A robotaxi pulls in, and the spinning dome on its roof lights up with two big letters so you know it's yours. Then you notice that dodgy guy who was watching you in the restaurant is reading them too. He now knows your initials, which car is yours, and that you're getting into it alone.

Waymo riders see their initials, or two letters they've picked in the app, on that dome. Last month, Waymo was granted a patent built on the opposite instinct, a random code that is banned from hinting at who you are or where you're going.

HOW IT WORKS

Waymo, the California robotaxi company that grew out of Google, is targeting how users can easily find their car without the car announcing who they are.

The new October 2026 patent descends from a 2014 Google application. Co-inventor Dan Fredinburg was head of privacy at Google X.

You book on your phone, and a central dispatch system picks a free car, sends it your location and generates a signal. The filing imagines nonsense letters, numbers, colour sequences or a picture. Its own examples are "59007", "FLADSOR" and "the blue boat icon."

That signal has to pass a set of rules. It can't contain your name or any version of it (for a rider called Robert, "bob" and "bert" are out). It can't point to where you are, where you've been or where you're heading, even indirectly. And it can't be reused for you, or for anyone nearby within a set window.

The car keeps tracking your phone as it approaches. Once it crosses a threshold (the filing suggests two minutes out, or about two city blocks), it lights the code on an exterior display, only on the screens facing you. In one version, the car doesn't even hold the code until then.

Your phone shows the same code. Match it, get in.

The detail that changes the stakes is why codes can't repeat. The filing says it's so a rider's trip patterns become hard or impossible to work out. Waymo is guarding against the person watching the street, as well as the database.

Dispatch can even withhold the code from whoever booked the ride, protecting the person actually being picked up.

If it works as described, the curb leaks nothing a bystander can use. Everything else about the trip still flows through Waymo's servers.

THE PROBLEM

The cars are currently causing leaks of personal information. Their privacy issues go far beyond potential onlookers trying to figure out your initials and then figuring out where your Waymos typically go.

Last year we highlighted research showing that cars are the worst product for consumer privacy.

Modern vehicles log where they go and how they're driven, then send it home through an app most owners set up at the dealership.

Northeastern University and Consumer Reports intercepted traffic from 21 cars and 30 companion apps and found 28 of the 30 apps contacted at least one advertising or analytics company. Seven sent names, emails or precise location.

GM's OnStar app told more than 370,000 drivers they weren't enrolled in Smart Driver when they were.

"People bought a car, not a tracking device."

Dan Rayfield, Oregon Attorney General

There is also a real bottleneck that most car owners aren't interrogating their own vehicle's privacy. The car's privacy gets set once, at the dealership.

WHO'S SOLVING IT?

This week, we're looking at the moves car companies have taken to remediate the privacy issue we highlighted one year ago.

Waymo's product currently puts the passenger's initials on the rooftop light, the exact thing their new patent's first rule forbids. Riders can change the letters, but the default runs on identity. To complement the outer-cabin patent activity, in 2025, a draft Waymo privacy policy surfaced letting riders opt out of interior camera data tied to their identity training generative AI. So Waymo is certainly taking steps to think about the scrutiny on cars as a poor privacy product category.

Volvo Cars has the best technical cousin. Its patent granted in July describes a car that switches off cameras and location tracking when it enters an area where they're restricted. There, the map decides when privacy kicks in.

Ford is pulling in two directions. Its November Privacy Promise pledges never to sell driving data to brokers, yet opting out disables BlueCruise and app location. Although, Ford has shown they're interested in collecting plenty of personal data. Its filings also include an in-cabin biometric system that scans faces… which came with its own controversy.

Privacy4Cars is interested in what happens after the car sale. Its DisconnectedCar product, launched in June, cuts off previous owners' remote access when a connected car changes hands.

Waymo's patent solves the one moment of the trip that happens in public. The past year showed big leaks happening inside apps and broker contracts. Waymo already owns the car, the app and the screen, which leaves an awkward question. Why isn't its own patent the default?

THE MARKET

Sundar Pichai said on 29 April that Waymo had "surpassed 500,000 fully autonomous rides per week, doubling in less than a year" (InsideEVs). That works out to roughly 71,000 trips a day. In 2025 alone, Waymo more than tripled its annual volume to 15 million rides (Fortune). Its stated target is over one million rides per week by the end of 2026.

Estimates for automotive data monetisation run from US$0.57 billion to US$7.8 billion to US$24.6 billion for 2024 and 2025. The highest is more than 40 times the lowest. The fuzziness suits automakers, because a market without edges is hard to regulate.

Analysts do agree on the biggest buyer. Technavio says usage-based insurance held the largest revenue share in 2024, the exact pipeline GM got fined for.

Now compare that with what the industry spends protecting the data. Estimates for automotive cybersecurity, the closest category with real money in it, sit between US$3.24 billion and US$7.13 billion for 2025. Estimates for automotive consent management range from US$412.7 million in 2024 to US$2.1 billion in 2025. Even the generous numbers make protecting car data worth a fraction of selling it.

Waymo raised US$16 billion at a US$126 billion valuation in February on roughly US$350 million in 2025 revenue. Waymo controls the vehicle, app, dispatch and roof display, so it can enforce a privacy rule end to end. A GM or Honda has to trust whatever third-party code sits inside its app.

PENALTIES VS DEAL FLOW

The FTC finalised its GM order in January with a five-year ban on sharing driver data with consumer reporting agencies and no fine. California followed in May with US$12.75 million, the largest CCPA penalty to date, after fining Ford US$375,703 in March.

Then the big one. On 29 October, GM agreed to pay US$220 million to 36 states and accept a third-party privacy assessment. The Register put that at less than 7% of GM's US$3.3 billion third-quarter net income.

The Scar

GM's Smart Driver program died in April 2024, and the bills keep arriving. Oregon says GM made more than US$20 million selling the data. Settlements now top US$230 million, and Texas is still suing.

Now follow the capital. The biggest cheque by far went to the company with the most cameras. Waymo's US$16 billion February round lifted its valuation from US$45 billion in 2024 to US$126 billion.

Security is consolidating at modest prices. KPIT Technologies, an Indian automotive software firm, agreed in May to buy Cymotive, a Tel Aviv vehicle-cybersecurity company co-founded with Volkswagen's software unit, for US$60 million to US$120 million, even as its revenue fell from US$42.4 million in 2023 to US$19.2 million in 2025.

The dedicated privacy players stay small. AiDEN Auto, which builds consent controls for automakers, raised a US$4.2 million seed in early 2025.

WHAT NEXT?

Your next robotaxi might flash "ASDFGH" instead of your initials, a code useless to anyone who saw it twice… but there's still research suggesting that your car is leaking more personal data than your smartphone!

Waymo has kept this patent family alive through six continuations since 2014. That upkeep could point to a company that wants to own the private pickup, as a default or as leverage over rivals.

So, are cars still the worst privacy product category? On this year's evidence, yes… because what is in the patents has little in the real world to show for implementation. But, the movement (and sanctions) does show that these robotaxis are probably gearing up to change their ways.

This week's patent is US 12,767,043 B1, titled 'Unique signaling for vehicles to preserve user privacy', authored by Waymo LLC.

Read the claims, then reply with your own answer, or find us on Instagram and LinkedIn.

FOR THE NERDS

•  The wire-level evidence with Northeastern University: Read "Automatic Transmission," the peer-reviewed study that measured what 21 cars and 30 apps actually sent, instead of what their privacy policies promised.

•  The GM order, in full with the Federal Trade Commission: See what "affirmative express consent" now means for the largest US automaker, and how long the rules last.

•  Privacy by geography with Google Patents: Explore Volvo's US 12,675,601, a technical cousin to this week's filing that switches sensors off in restricted zones.

•  When the car becomes a stalking tool with CalMatters: Learn how survivors were being tracked through connected-car apps, and why California wrote a law to stop it.

•  The 2026 state privacy map with Nelson Mullins: Zoom out to the state laws banning precise-geolocation sales, which are reshaping what automakers can do with location data.

Hot Off the Patent Press
Enjoying this issue?
Get one like it every Sunday. Free.